Pdf the state of the science and technology in deep. The answer to this question is a heated debate that involves everybody from politicians pushing. Pdf disposal of highlevel nuclear waste in deep horizontal. Professor kinkade rws 280 analysis of nuclear waste richard a. Nuclear fuel cycle barc highlights 109 waste management. Initially, the most dangerous part of this waste is not. However, is it really dangerous or is it just harmful to an extent. In early 2010, muller and his daughter elizabeth founded the group berkeley earth, an independent 501c3 nonprofit aimed at addressing some of the major concerns of the climate.
Use the templates in they sayi say for representing the words of others and for introducing quotations. Container materials for the storage and disposal of. Why would it be such a great idea to redesign nuclear power plants to run on spent nuclear fuel. The whole purpose of this writing was to deliver information based off of his studies and his confessions on nuclear waste. The answer to this question is a heated debate that involves everybody from politicians pushing for policy they dont really understand to scientists who are trying to. Timo seppala finland, richard poisson france, ingo mullerlyda germany. The federal government did not meet its contractual obligation begin acceptingto used nuclear fuel by 1998. Richard muller, physicist from the university of california, berkeley recently released energy for future presidents. Flynn by the year 2000, the united states will have a projected 40,000 metric tons of spent nuclear fuel stored and awaiting disposal at some seventy. Jeffrey ly professor stephen english 121 honors 12 oct 2010 essay 2 draft 2 nuclear waste by richard a. Spent nuclear fuel is the radioactive waste that is created by current nuclear power generation. But i have seen at least some of his arguments on the matter. He is a fellow of the aps and of the aaas, and his awards include the texas instruments founders prize, the nsf alan t. Muller starts his argument by stating that nuclear waste doesn 39.
Energies thermal evolution near heatgenerating nuclear waste. Muller speaks on scientific research about nuclear waste storage, other peoples theories, and alternative ways of storing this type of waste. Rhetorical analysis nuclear waste anthony white eng. Scholarships expiring soon forums general scholarship discussion nuclear waste richard a muller essay 828076 this topic contains 0 replies, has 1 voice, and was last updated by preachmytilluto 2 years ago. Assessing the corrosion performance of highlevel nuclear. Deep isolations solution to nuclear waste disposal. Container materials for the storage and disposal of nuclear waste. Nuclear waste is produced from industrial, medical and scientific processes that use radioactive material. Muller is professor of physics at the university of california, berkeley. Similarly to the others, i, too, am not richard muller. Muller, it is possible to come across a number of different metacommentaries used by the author with the purpose to make sure that the readers can correctly understand the reasons of the elaborated information and make sure that the data presented in the discussion is valid but with the shade of personal meaning. Chemical and nuclear waste disposal problems and solutions. What are prof richard mullers ideas on storage of nuclear.
Pdf spent nuclear fuel and highlevel radioactive waste can be disposed in. The federal government did not meet its contractual obligation begin. Energies thermal evolution near heatgenerating nuclear. Spent nuclear fuel and highlevel radioactive waste can be disposed in deep horizontal drillholes in sedimentary, metamorphic or igneous rocks.
The idea is to transmute this nuclear waste into new forms of atoms which dont. Muller starts his argument by stating that nuclear waste doesnt decay for thousands of years and that trying to store it for 10,000 years in the future is impossible. Mar 22, 2018 i believe the best solution is to put nuclear waste in horizontal drillholes a mile underground. Lessons from yucca mountain paul slavic, mark layman, and james h. Muller first brings to light the most common fears of storing nuclear waste. Nuclear waste is the leftover nucleus of elements that were split and the result of nuclear fuel. The company was founded by the father and daughter team of richard and elizabeth muller. Oct 19, 2010 essay 2 draft 2 nuclear waste by richard a.
Cofounder and executive director of berkeley earth. Disposal of radioactive waste the waste overpack and the host rock mainly to restrict the groundwater flow towards the waste form and to retard the migration of radionuclides in the event of their release from the overpack. Deep isolation nuclear waste disposal southern states energy. A wide range of alloys have been considered as candidate container materials for the storage and disposal of nuclear waste. How have nuclear waste management procedures improved. Muller, course hero nuclear waste is dangerous, isn 39. Richard muller explaines nuclear meltdown and chernobyl. Report from the swedish national council for nuclear waste, stockholm 2016. Nuclear plants produce waste while generating electricity, but its not glowing green goo like you see in the movies or the simpsons. What is remarkable is that others havent thought of this, but we think that is the result of us government policy that doesnt allow private companies or individ.
Jan 07, 2015 richard muller became the darling of the climate denial community a few years ago when he made a number of statements questioning the integrity of climate scientists and science. Download as docx, pdf, txt or read online from scribd. Richard ausness, highlevel radioactive waste management. In a recent video interview with the wall street journal, muller said that despite the fact that the accident at fukushima was far less. Mar 12, 2004 more research on nuclear waste storage. The project was initiated by rebecca harms, and the original. His popular science book physics for future presidents and academic textbook physics and technology for future presidents are based on his renowned course for nonscience students. I find the story surrounding richard muller interesting for several reasons, at the end of the post i will provide my own analysis. Your goal for this assignment is to summarize the articles main ideas and important points clearly, concisely, and accurately. Nuclear waste richard a muller essay 828076 grants and. This is safe its under a billion tons of rock, and inexpensive for a few million dollars we can drill a hole that is a mile deep and two miles lon. Horizontal drillhole disposal has safety, operational and economic benefits. Aug 04, 2012 by judith curry the story surrounding richard muller is providing some interesting insights into the psychodynamics of climate change science. He is also a faculty senior scientist at the lawrence berkeley national laboratory.
It may be a new manifestation of an old jungian archetype. Richard muller became the darling of the climate denial community a few years ago when he made a number of statements questioning the integrity of. Ive tried to find them again but its been kinda difficult, so ill state what i recall him saying, as well as my two cents. Muller nuclear waste is a radioactive waste that is dangerous, and a fair percentage of people would agree on this topic. The following is excerpted, with permission of the author, from physics for future presidents the science behind the headlines. Muller born january 6, 1944 is an american physicist and professor of physics at the university of california, berkeley. Muller the article, nuclear waste, by richard muller discusses the dangers of nuclear waste and his criticism of how important figures are handling the situation. Timing of highlevel waste disposal nuclear energy agency. Richard muller is a professor of physics at the university of california at berkely. Physics for future presidents the science behind the. Nuclear waste can have detrimental effects on marine habitats.
In biblical times, the residents of jerusalem always burnt their wastes in the hideous vale ofgehenna. Muller energy for future presidents is the educational, informative and accessible book on energy. While the question may be simple, the answer is quite complex. The progressive radio network website had a fascinating interview with prof richard muller last week following his man of the moment opinion piece the conversion of a climate change sceptic in the new york times 28th july 2012. May 16, 2010 richard muller is a professor of physics at the university of california at berkely. Initially, what waste packages is deep isolation looking to use this technology for. Highlevel radioactive waste hlw accumulated since the early.
The irresistable story of richard muller climate etc. The underground tunnels at yucca mountain are designed to hold 77,000 tons of highlevel nuclear waste. Macarthur genius and founder of two projects that led to. Mar 12, 2004 more research on nuclear waste storage wont reassure the public. Rector 3, joe payer 4 and john apps 5 1 deep isolation inc. Aug 01, 2019 nuclear energy may be the best candidate for the future, but we are still left with a lot of dangerous junk. However, we need a lot of innovative and multidisciplinary research to put this vision into reality. A fascinating new interview with prof richard muller, quote.
Summary of nuclear waste nuclear waste is dangerous, isnt it. When most people talk about nuclear waste, theyre referring to fuel thats been used in a reactor once. What are prof richard mullers ideas on storage of nuclear waste. Nuclear waste is much different from what you might think. Waste disposal for nuclear power plants a technologically solved challenge. Present disposal designs and concepts are analyzed on scientific bases and modifications to the existing designs are proposed. Spent nuclear fuel and highlevel radioactive waste can be disposed in deep. Anthony white eng 2 83018 professor wu 22 february 2014 rhetorical analysis nuclear waste in nuclear waste richard muller takes on the issue of storing nuclear biproducts inside the yucca mountain in nevada. In the essay nuclear waste, author richard muller expresses his concern about how to dispose of nuclear waste. Muller nuclear waste is dangerousjust about anyone knows that. The phaseout of nuclear energy in germany will take place in 2022.
Elizabeth, who serves as deep isolations chief execu. Muller, a professor of physics at the university of california at berkeley, gives his thoughts on the matter of nuclear waste in his essay entitled nuclear waste. Muller, an awardee of the macarthur fellowship and physics professor at uc berkley, states in his 2008 essay nuclear waste, that americans and the rest of the world are overly concerned with radioactive debris and the possibility of nuclear contamination. Muller, an awardee of the macarthur fellowship and physics professor at uc berkley, states in his 2008 essay nuclear waste, that americans and the rest of the world are overly concerned with radioactive debris and. This was a nerveracking day for liz muller, cofounder of california startup technology company deep isolation and her father, richard muller. Strategy for the management and disposal of used nuclear fuel and highlevel radioactive waste 3 generators pay the full cost of the disposal of their used nuclear fuel and highlevel radioactive waste. The furor against nuclear power has been so intense that i felt compelled to reproduce the antinuke viewpoint in the opening of this chapter, including at least part of their. In society, many debates are held over trying to prove to the world that this substance is harmful. Disposal of highlevel nuclear waste in deep horizontal drillholes richard a. Nuclear waste policy act in 1982 and its amendment in 1987, by which yucca mountain, nevada, was selected as the only candidate site for the nations first nuclear waste repository. Muller, stefan finsterle, john grimsich, rod baltzer, elizabeth a. The goal of the majority of national nuclear waste management programs is the ultimate disposal of the waste, although, depending upon the strategy being followed, disposal may come only after an extended period of storage. Physics for future presidents the science behind the headlines.
Muller 1, stefan finsterle 2, john grimsich 1, rod baltzer 1. The demonstration we did was for smaller waste packages, but we are certainly interested in spent nuclear fuel. Introduction the problems of waste disposal have always been with us. Muller 1, stefan finsterle 2, john grimsich 1, rod baltzer 1, elizabeth a. The images, tables and graphics contained in the brochure may. Disposal of highlevel nuclear waste in deep horizontal drillholes. More research on nuclear waste storage wont reassure the public.
Nuclear waste richard a muller essay click here essay about the turn of the screw the fact writing an essay gcse english the sun bore down on my head hotter friend an unhappy creative writing essay tips helped can i write an. Jun 25, 2014 nuclear waste richard a muller essay click here essay about the turn of the screw the fact writing an essay gcse english the sun bore down on my head hotter friend an unhappy creative writing essay tips helped can i write an. Muller starts his argument by stating that nuclear waste doesnt decay for thousands of years and that trying to store it for 10,000 years in the future is. This brochure provides information about disposal of the residual materials and waste accumulating in german nuclear power plants. Translated into english by richard nord translation. Muller, genetic damage produced by radiation, 121 sc. My daughter elizabeth and i have found the obvious way to dispose off nuclear waste. Sep 20, 2012 richard muller, physicist from the university of california, berkeley recently released energy for future presidents. In society, many debates are held over trying to prove to the world that this. Discussion creating nuclear power stations that can run on existing nuclear waste is a worthy endeavor, and our feasibility analysis shows that it can likely be done. But is it really that dangerous or is it simply overstated.
Disposal of highlevel nuclear waste in deep horizontal. A site for final disposal of highlevel radioactive waste hlrw has not yet been chosen, but a site selection process was. Radioactive waste project director, nuclear information and resource service. Is access to nuclear energy worth the risk of creating nuclear waste. Nuclear waste is dangerousjust about anyone knows that. Operations conducted by nuclear power stations produce radioactive waste. Apr 12, 2015 the article, nuclear waste, by richard muller discusses the dangers of nuclear waste and his criticism of how important figures are handling the situation.
Manuscript submitted to energies, 12202018 thermal evolution near heatgenerating nuclear waste canisters disposed in horizontal drillholes stefan finsterle 1, richard a. His etiquette throughout this journal was very studious. The world nuclear waste report 2019 5 the world nuclear waste report wnwr is a common project by a group of renowned experts who want to draw more attention to radioactive waste as a significant and growing challenge with no longterm solutions yet available. Nuclear energy may be the best candidate for the future, but we are still left with a lot of dangerous junk. How have the waste management procedures improved over the years for the nuclear reactors. Muller at columbia university in new york city was able to show that. Tourism argumentative example essay problemfocused assessment is an ongoing process integrated with nursing care to determine the status of a specific.
485 1521 965 686 534 1573 1398 1461 910 486 791 1208 167 990 39 561 1379 61 1074 1325 725 517 78 1083 424 1119 184 1624 1000 172 1636 838 1422 1298 1458 96 853 813 737